International Stocks: Four Factors Behind the Gap

International Stocks: Four Factors Behind the Gap

A narrowing of the advantages recently enjoyed by U.S. companies could reverse the international stock performance gap.

Key Takeaways

  • The historical performance advantage of U.S. over international equities has expanded meaningfully over the last decade.
  • We attribute the performance gap to 1) higher free cash flow, 2) higher share repurchases and 3) superior earnings of U.S. companies as well as 4) the growth-heavy composition of the U.S. equity market.
  • A narrowing of these advantages, due partially to non-U.S. companies adopting many U.S. management practices, should also continue and potentially reverse the current stock performance gap.


Higher Free Cash Flows Power U.S. Equity Returns

Over the past 30 years, U.S. stocks have outperformed the rest of the world by about 500 basis points on an annualized basis. This advantage has expanded over the last decade to 800 basis points.

No single factor explains this historic performance gap, as macroeconomic differences account for only a small portion of the underperformance of non-U.S. markets. Relative valuations are important to longer-term returns but in isolation provide little help in determining the timing and magnitude of relative performance cycles.

We believe that four underlying factors have driven the superior gains in U.S. shares. Importantly, the relative expansion or contraction of these metrics align well with the relative performance of international equities.

The first metric  is the higher free cash flows of U.S. companies. Domestic stocks have enjoyed an average free cash flow margin premium of about 400 basis points over the past 30 years. When this gap contracts toward 200 basis points, relative performance improves for international markets, according to Empirical Research Partners. This last occurred in the decade of the 2000s.

U.S. Companies Generate Higher Free Cash Flow


Line graph showing MSCI US and MSCI EAFE free cash flow since 1999

Source: FactSet, as of 9/30/18. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Indexes are unmanaged, and not available for direct investment. Index returns do not include fees or sales charges. This information is provided for illustrative purposes only and does not reflect the performance of an actual investment.


The combination of lower capital intensity and free cash flows leads to the second driver of U.S. outperformance: share repurchases. Over the past 10 years, American firms have been decreasing share count while outside of the U.S., companies have been in net issuance. Empirical points out that top share repurchasers have earned a performance premium of about 200 basis points historically.

A robust supply of private equity funding and record expansion of corporate debt has allowed U.S. public companies to reduce total market capitalization an average of 3% per year since 2008. This contraction contrasts with the annualized common equity expansion in Europe of 1.7% and is cited by Gavekal Research as a driver of the poor performance of continental shares. International management teams have tended to favor returning cash to shareholders via dividends, which has not been a consistent source of alpha over the past two decades.

Growth in Share Buybacks Has Fueled U.S. Stock Returns


Combination line and column chart showing S&P 500 dividends, S&P 500 share buybacks and S&P index value since 1995

Sources: Credit Suisse, S&P and Bloomberg. S&P 500 as of September 30, 2018. Remainder as of June 30, 2018, most recent available as of September 30, 2018. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Indexes are unmanaged, and not available for direct investment. Index returns do not include fees or sales charges. This information is provided for illustrative purposes only and does not reflect the performance of an actual investment.


Shrinking the equity base with the use of free cash flow and debt has served to support a third advantage for U.S. firms: superior earnings growth and returns on equity (ROE). This gap has widened significantly in the past decade, especially relative to Europe. U.S. firms have generally enjoyed a sales growth advantage over the past 30 years, but the last decade’s divergence in earnings per share is unprecedented. This jump in relative profits occurred in the context of sub-par global growth, powering an expansion in U.S. valuation premiums.

Historically, American companies have maintained a consistently higher ROE and relative share performance appears to correlate well with the contraction or expansion of this gap. In the 1990s, when the ROE premium averaged 900 basis points, the U.S. outperformed non-U.S. markets by an annualized 1,200 basis points. When this difference was cut in half in the 2000s, international markets posted relative average yearly gains of 260 basis points. In the most recent decade, U.S. ROE have climbed back to a 600 basis-point advantage, driving about 800 basis points of annual outperformance. 

Return on Equity for U.S. vs. Developed Market Companies


Line graph showing the return on equity for the MSCI US and MSCI EAFE indexes for the past 20 years

Source: Bloomberg, as of 9/30/18. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Indexes are unmanaged, and not available for direct investment. Index returns do not include fees or sales charges. This information is provided for illustrative purposes only and does not reflect the performance of an actual investment.


Lastly, a large portion of the divergences we have highlighted can be attributed to market composition effects.  The U.S. enjoys a higher weighting of “new economy” technology and growth stocks while the rest of the world has a much larger share of “old economy” financial and cyclical companies. Technology shares account for over 20% of the U.S. stock market as measured by the Russell 3000 Index compared with only a little over 6% in the developed international markets as measured by the MSCI EAFE Index.  The parabolically rising “FAANGS” alone total about 11% of the Russell 3000, up from just 2% in 2008.  This leads us to observe that when the proportion of the fastest-growing companies in the world domiciled in the U.S. is rising, international markets tend to struggle. Over the past decade the representation of U.S. firms in the top quintile of growth has expanded from 35% to approximately 80%, according to growth score metrics compiled by Empirical Research Partners.


Over the past three decades, the relative performance of international shares appears to have been driven by the directional shift in free cash flows, earnings growth and ROE as compared to U.S. companies. International shares outperformed during those periods when non-U.S. firms improved upon these metrics relative to American companies.  For the most recent 10-year period, this dynamic has been amplified by the profusion of share repurchases in the U.S. and an investment environment characterized by a rising premium for secular growth stocks which American markets had in abundance.

Currently, international equities offer the largest free cash flow yield premium of the past 30 years and are at historically extreme levels of undervaluation relative to U.S. markets. In addition, there are initial signs that the key metrics we have outlined are beginning to shift in support of better relative share price performance for non-U.S. markets. The heavily weighted U.S. tech stocks have begun to underperform as earnings growth and margins fall short of expectations. Rising borrowing costs and record high corporate debt, meanwhile, have started to reduce the positive impact of share repurchases. Negative estimate revisions and lowered management profit guidance are becoming more frequent in the U.S.

Meanwhile, company managements in China, Japan, Europe and many emerging markets are emulating their U.S. peers in focusing upon free cash flows, share buybacks and industry consolidation, which should improve capital returns in the future. On top of this, policy makers and central bankers are generally committed to reflation and economic stimulus that will eventually favor the “old economy” financial, consumer and cyclical shares that make up a relatively larger portion of the non-U.S. markets. 


Important Information


All investments involve risk, including possible loss of principal.

The value of investments and the income from them can go down as well as up and investors may not get back the amounts originally invested, and can be affected by changes in interest rates, in exchange rates, general market conditions, political, social and economic developments and other variable factors. Investment involves risks including but not limited to, possible delays in payments and loss of income or capital. Neither Legg Mason nor any of its affiliates guarantees any rate of return or the return of capital invested. 

Equity securities are subject to price fluctuation and possible loss of principal. Fixed-income securities involve interest rate, credit, inflation and reinvestment risks; and possible loss of principal. As interest rates rise, the value of fixed income securities falls.

International investments are subject to special risks including currency fluctuations, social, economic and political uncertainties, which could increase volatility. These risks are magnified in emerging markets.

Commodities and currencies contain heightened risk that include market, political, regulatory, and natural conditions and may not be suitable for all investors.

Past performance is no guarantee of future results.  Please note that an investor cannot invest directly in an index. Unmanaged index returns do not reflect any fees, expenses or sales charges.

The opinions and views expressed herein are not intended to be relied upon as a prediction or forecast of actual future events or performance, guarantee of future results, recommendations or advice.  Statements made in this material are not intended as buy or sell recommendations of any securities. Forward-looking statements are subject to uncertainties that could cause actual developments and results to differ materially from the expectations expressed. This information has been prepared from sources believed reliable but the accuracy and completeness of the information cannot be guaranteed. Information and opinions expressed by either Legg Mason or its affiliates are current as at the date indicated, are subject to change without notice, and do not take into account the particular investment objectives, financial situation or needs of individual investors.

The information in this material is confidential and proprietary and may not be used other than by the intended user. Neither Legg Mason or its affiliates or any of their officer or employee of Legg Mason accepts any liability whatsoever for any loss arising from any use of this material or its contents. This material may not be reproduced, distributed or published without prior written permission from Legg Mason. Distribution of this material may be restricted in certain jurisdictions. Any persons coming into possession of this material should seek advice for details of, and observe such restrictions (if any).

This material may have been prepared by an advisor or entity affiliated with an entity mentioned below through common control and ownership by Legg Mason, Inc.  Unless otherwise noted the “$” (dollar sign) represents U.S. Dollars.

This material is approved for distribution in those countries and to those recipients listed below. Note: this material may not be available in all regions listed.

All investors and eligible counterparties in Europe, the UK, Switzerland:

In Europe (excluding UK and Switzerland), this financial promotion is issued by Legg Mason Investments (Ireland) Limited, registered office 6th Floor, Building Three, Number One Ballsbridge, 126 Pembroke Road, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4, D04 EP27. Registered in Ireland, Company No. 271887. Authorised and regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland.

All Qualified Investors in Switzerland:
In Switzerland, this financial promotion is issued by Legg Mason Investments (Switzerland) GmbH, authorised by the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority FINMA.  Investors in Switzerland: The representative in Switzerland is FIRST INDEPENDENT FUND SERVICES LTD., Klausstrasse 33, 8008 Zurich, Switzerland and the paying agent in Switzerland is NPB Neue Privat Bank AG, Limmatquai 1, 8024 Zurich, Switzerland. Copies of the Articles of Association, the Prospectus, the Key Investor Information documents and the annual and semi-annual reports of the Company may be obtained free of charge from the representative in Switzerland.

All investors in the UK:
In the UK this financial promotion is issued by Legg Mason Investments (Europe) Limited, registered office 201 Bishopsgate, London EC2M 3AB. Registered in England and Wales, Company No. 1732037. Authorized and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Client Services +44 (0)207 070 7444

All Investors in Hong Kong and Singapore:

This material is provided by Legg Mason Asset Management Hong Kong Limited in Hong Kong and Legg Mason Asset Management Singapore Pte. Limited (Registration Number (UEN): 200007942R) in Singapore.

This material has not been reviewed by any regulatory authority in Hong Kong or Singapore.

All Investors in the People’s Republic of China ("PRC"):

This material is provided by Legg Mason Asset Management Hong Kong Limited to intended recipients in the PRC.  The content of this document is only for Press or the PRC investors investing in the QDII Product offered by PRC’s commercial bank in accordance with the regulation of China Banking Regulatory Commission.  Investors should read the offering document prior to any subscription.  Please seek advice from PRC’s commercial banks and/or other professional advisors, if necessary. Please note that Legg Mason and its affiliates are the Managers of the offshore funds invested by QDII Products only.  Legg Mason and its affiliates are not authorized by any regulatory authority to conduct business or investment activities in China.

This material has not been reviewed by any regulatory authority in the PRC.

Distributors and existing investors in Korea and Distributors in Taiwan:

This material is provided by Legg Mason Asset Management Hong Kong Limited to eligible recipients in Korea and by Legg Mason Investments (Taiwan) Limited (Registration Number: (98) Jin Guan Tou Gu Xin Zi Di 001; Address: Suite E, 55F, Taipei 101 Tower, 7, Xin Yi Road, Section 5, Taipei 110, Taiwan, R.O.C.; Tel: (886) 2-8722 1666) in Taiwan. Legg Mason Investments (Taiwan) Limited operates and manages its business independently.

This material has not been reviewed by any regulatory authority in Korea or Taiwan.

All Investors in the Americas:

This material is provided by Legg Mason Investor Services LLC, a U.S. registered Broker-Dealer, which includes Legg Mason Americas International. Legg Mason Investor Services, LLC, Member FINRA/SIPC, and all entities mentioned are subsidiaries of Legg Mason, Inc.

All Investors in Australia and New Zealand:

This document is issued by Legg Mason Asset Management Australia Limited (ABN 76 004 835 839, AFSL 204827).  The information in this document is of a general nature only and is not intended to be, and is not, a complete or definitive statement of matters described in it. It has not been prepared to take into account the investment objectives, financial objectives or particular needs of any particular person.

Outperformance does not imply positive results.

Yields and dividends represent past performance and there is no guarantee they will continue to be paid.

Forecasts are inherently limited and should not be relied upon as indicators of actual or future performance.